Was this the greatest football match of all time?
Division Two. Saturday December 21, 1957
Charlton Athletic vs Huddersfield Town att. 12,535
"Amazing, fantastic, incredible...call it what you will" exclaimed the newspaper report from this game as the dust settled on the most remarkable comeback in the history of English football.
There was nothing to suggest that a classic encounter was on the cards in the run up to this game.
Although Charlton were handily placed on the fringe of the second division promotion race there was little in the visit of mid table Huddersfield Town to inspire the locals on the Saturday before Christmas.
Vast swathes of the huge Valley terraces were almost deserted as a below average crowd huddled together in clutches to create atmosphere and warmth and there was no immediate sign of their team doing anything to brighten their days.
After a quiet opening where the visitors looked marginally more lively, the first incident of note occurred in the 17th minute.
Charlton's skipper and centre half, Derek Ufton, threw himself into a challenge and landed awkwardly on the heavy pitch. Ufton had dislocated his shoulder and had to be carted off, in agony, to hospital.
In 1957, at a time before substitutions, Ufton's injury reduced Charlton to 10 men, with over 70 minutes left to play.
Charlton had shown little to this point and, struggling to reshuffle after the loss of Ufton, Huddersfield assumed control.
On 27 minutes the inevitable occurred, The Terriers inside left Les Massie firing home from point blank range to take the side to a 1-0 lead.
Eight minutes later Alex Bain took advantage of the freedom he had been given since Ufton's injury to take the visitors to 2-0 up at the break.
Supporters on the terraces decided to call it a day and many left at half time.
Meanwhile in the dressing room, the Charlton manager Jimmy Trotter tried to rally his troops, urging his team to feed left winger Johnny Summers, Charlton's one potential source of danger in an otherwise lacklustre field. Sure enough, two minutes into the second half the tactics were rewarded as Summers broke through to make it 2-1.
But just four minutes later, Huddersfield swept into a 4-1 lead through Alex Bain's second goal and a Bill McGarry penalty.
This prompted a further trickle towards the exits, but the trickle turned into a stream when Bobby Ledger was left unmarked to slot home the visitors fifth just past the hour mark. 5-1 to Huddersfield.
With 28 minutes to play Charlton were a man short and four goals in arrears. The game was surely over. There seemed no way back.
THE COMEBACK
First, Summers centred for Johnny "Buck" Ryan to score - 5-2 - and then the winger instilled some real belief into the Valley by firing home his second and Charlton's third. 5-3 Huddersfield.
This time Charlton maintained their sudden momentum and Huddersfield inexplicably fell apart.
On 73 minutes Summers completed his hat trick. 5-4 Huddersfield.
Five minutes later The Addicks were level. Once more it was Summers. Unbelievably, 10 man Charlton had bought the match back from 5-1 down to 5-5.
By now the loss of their centre half hardly seeemed to matter as Charlton poured forward at will.
With nine minutes remaining the comeback was complete as Summers rammed home an astonishing fifth goal to put Charlton 6-5 in front.
But with four minutes remaining Stan Howard sent in a shot which deflected off John Hewie and beyond the wrong footed Willie Duff in the Charlton goal to even the match. 6-6 with four minutes to go.
The Charlton fans could have been forgiven for biting their nails and shrieking for the final whistle but they had become too caught up in the manic events of the last half hour.
With the clock ticking down the last few seconds Johnny Summers set off on one final burst, tearing clear of the hapless Tony Conwell yet again to send over a cross which Ryan met perfectly for Charlton to take the lead, again, with barely time left to start the whistle.
The final score: 7-6 to Charlton.
A more tragic fate awaited Johnny Summers, the hero of this hour, who would die from cancer within five years of this unforgettable afternoon.
Charlton Athletic: W.Duff, T.Edwards, D.Townsend, J.Hewie, D.Ufton, B.Kiernan, R.White, F.Lucas, J.Ryan, S.Leary, J.Summers.
Huddersfield Town: S.Kennon, T.Conwell, R.Wilson, K.Taylor, J.Connor, B.McGarry, B.Ledger, S.Howard, A.Bain, L.Massie, R.Simpson.




